Board Logo

Ignition system...what is good?
HappyDaze - May 27th, 2013 at 08:15 AM

It was a very frustrating day at the Supersprints on Saturday, with a serious lack of power in No.8 Beetle.

There were a few suggestions as to what was causing the miss-firing, and I think Rene F. may have nailed it. Rene thought the higher compression of the 'new' 2276 engine may have been too much for the coil [which worked fine on the 'old' engine. He suggested using a Crane HI 6 set-up.

Anyone out there have any ideas on this? Any help welcome.

Cheers, Greg


cnfabo - May 27th, 2013 at 09:09 AM

Rene swears by that crane set up and he should know considering he has done a lot of dyno time with it and other systems...

Fabo


bat69 - May 27th, 2013 at 12:31 PM

I got a crane HI6 'fireball' system with a whole heap of other perfomance stuff for the race bug but never ended up using the crane as I ended up using a different system with the injection. I know there are a few circuit guys with escorts using this system on their BDA's. That's were mine come from. Its just sitting in the shed if your interested.


HappyDaze - May 27th, 2013 at 12:45 PM

PM sent, bat.


sander288 - May 27th, 2013 at 01:46 PM

twin spark?

But I've spoken to Rene about his setup and he absolutely swears by it; it also is a much easier install


MickH - May 27th, 2013 at 06:07 PM

The Crane systems rock!!!!


dangerous - May 27th, 2013 at 06:21 PM

Start by closing the plug gap a little, say to .018", then you can tell if it is a lack of ignition.

I have run 10:1 and 42psi boost with a stock early WBX ignition and it worked fine with close gaps,
although I will be the first to admit that a better ignition would have made more power.

I would be chasing a 'fault' rather than an upgrade,
since most ignition problems are fuel problems.


colin - May 27th, 2013 at 08:01 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by dangerous
Start by closing the plug gap a little, say to .018", then you can tell if it is a lack of ignition.

I have run 10:1 and 42psi boost with a stock early WBX ignition and it worked fine with close gaps,
although I will be the first to admit that a better ignition would have made more power.

I would be chasing a 'fault' rather than an upgrade,
since most ignition problems are fuel problems.


Would have to agree with Dave, before you upgrade or change anything I would be looking to find out the fault. Then address the solution with a upgrade or other.
Good luck, fault finding can be frustrating.

Cheers Col


colin - May 27th, 2013 at 08:04 PM

What heat range plug did you use?, higher comp likes a cooler plug.

Cheers Col


HappyDaze - May 27th, 2013 at 08:53 PM

The plugs were NGK B7ES. Comp. is 11.5 : 1. Fuel - BP 98.

Had some input today from an old friend, who has years of experience with race engines. Alf thinks the problem started when I first started the engine in the morning, when the temp. was about 2 degrees. He believes the plugs 'cold fouled', and did not fire properly after that. Makes sense to me.

Will be doing some looking at the fuel system, float levels, etc, etc. as well.

Dave, I agree about finding the 'fault' first. As this was the first time I have run the 'new' engine, it will be a case of 'sorting it out'.:yes:

Thanks for the input...it all helps.


DubbyDo - May 27th, 2013 at 09:11 PM

"I have run 10:1 and 42psi boost with a stock early WBX ignition and it worked fine with close gaps"
You wouldnt even need plugs when it was running on boost would ya:lol:


HappyDaze - June 6th, 2013 at 08:55 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by bat69
I got a crane HI6 'fireball' system with a whole heap of other perfomance stuff for the race bug but never ended up using the crane as I ended up using a different system with the injection. I know there are a few circuit guys with escorts using this system on their BDA's. That's were mine come from. Its just sitting in the shed if your interested.

HI 6 arrived today - thanks Nathan. If I can figure out the wiring, it will be going again soon......without the bad miss-fire.

Thanks also to Rene for the advice.


Grey 57 - June 6th, 2013 at 11:01 PM

Been running a Crane Hi6 for years on my 2.4ltr Porsche engine in my T34 Ghia. Really happy with it and no troubles at all.


psimitar - June 7th, 2013 at 12:10 AM

Have you rolling roaded the engine to make sure you have correct AFR across the rev range and engine loads?

Got an AFR set up in your exhaust. Great way to self tune the jetting.

I'm assuming the Hi8 is an older version of the current Hi6 CDI multi spark ignition system? So similar to the MSD AL6?

Will certainly make sure that if the spark is being 'blown out' by the compression ratio the CDI should cure that.

Sooty plugs is a very real possibility too.

Still least you have a few avenues to go down to try and eliminate the issue :)


dangerous - June 7th, 2013 at 05:12 AM

now you have a better ignition you can use a colder plug as well!


HappyDaze - June 7th, 2013 at 07:37 AM

Dave, hopefully the NGK 7s will be OK. Interestingly Crane recommend .045" gaps, for the HI 6.:starhit: I'm saying well away from any wires when the engine is running.:yes:

Psim, the AFR looks good on the dyno sheets that Ben gave me, however I will be re-checking it. I intend to fit smaller venturis, so it will need to be re-done.

Are those AFR gauges any good? It would be handy to have an ACCURATE reading , although it's another bloody gauge to look at.


psimitar - June 8th, 2013 at 12:07 AM

Well they work off the same sensor as an ECU Lambda sensor as far as I'm aware.

As for accuracy the electronics are pretty simple but as always a more expensive brand will likely be more accurate and reliable than a cheaper brand.

Saw loads of the turbo boys in the UK using them to make sure they didn't cook the engine at full boost.