Board Logo

Generator "sloppy" - bearings or replace/upgrade?
pfillery - May 20th, 2014 at 08:06 AM

When fixing my fuel pump last night I noticed my fanbelt a little loose. There appears to be a bit more than the normal expected play at the pulley end of the generator, that is to say I can lift the pulley towards the top of the engine bay and take up the slack in the belt. Pulley is tight on thje shaft so I'm attributing it to the bearing at the end of the genny.

Is there an option to replace a bearing or simply replace the generator?

What about going to an alternator? Pros and cons? I don't really need an alternator or extra power but it seems to be an upgrade a lot of folk do.

Engine is a 1600 type 1.


matberry - May 20th, 2014 at 08:57 AM

A bearing is $10 an alternator is $200

The only reason you would replace the gen would be if the bearing housing was damaged, otherwise the bearing replacement and even reco while you're there would be the most simple.
If you want an alternator, you'll need a kit with stand and backing plates and mods to the wiring are required, all doable but all take time and $$, and get a good one, many copies are rubbish.


vduboy - May 20th, 2014 at 11:56 AM

Quote:
Originally posted by matberry
A bearing is $10 an alternator is $200

The only reason you would replace the gen would be if the bearing housing was damaged, otherwise the bearing replacement and even reco while you're there would be the most simple.
If you want an alternator, you'll need a kit with stand and backing plates and mods to the wiring are required, all doable but all take time and $$, and get a good one, many copies are rubbish.

Sorry for the hi jack, what are the good ones Mat? I think my old external regulated Motorola one is a bit weak and might have to replace it soon..


pfillery - May 20th, 2014 at 12:06 PM

Thanks Matt.

Obviously my preference is to fix what I've got, don't really have a need to go to an alternator, the genny seems to do just fine.

Is it a case of going to a bearing supplier and taking the old one in or is there a specific part I can order up front? Any idea of the part number/brand?

Can the bearing be changed in the car or does the genny have to come out?


vwo60 - May 20th, 2014 at 01:30 PM

You probably will find that the OD of the bearing has been spinning in the housing causing wear, i have loctited bearings in before to fix this issue, you will need to pull it apart to confirm that is the issue. if it is worn to far you could sorce a end cover in better condition.


matberry - May 20th, 2014 at 06:32 PM

The alternators I use are from Vintage Vee Dub. Boris gets a Chinese brand specially made with better bearings. A good price and over the last few years I've had 100% reliability with the few I've sold/fitted.
I agree with Shayne, pull it apart, checK whats required first. With your description of the amount of play, the housing may be a problem so it would pay to check first.
By memory the bearings are 6209 but please check. They are common and easily sourced at an auto electrician or bearing shop
You might consider removing the gen (which you definately need to do) and taking the lot to an auto electrician, there are some difficult operations involved like pulling the bearings and undoing the fan nut depending on what tools you have. Even getting the gennie out can prove to be challenging for some.


57oval - May 20th, 2014 at 06:51 PM

New Bosch alternators still available instaed of Chinese junk.....
http://vwparts.aircooled.net/12V-Alternator-BOSCH-Upright-Engines-AL-82-p/bos...


vw54 - May 20th, 2014 at 07:17 PM

I think the bearings are 6203 very common and cheap get the ZZ ones as they are greased and sealed

If that's not the number when you pull the generator apart the number is on end of bearing too easy


vduboy - May 20th, 2014 at 08:37 PM

Cool thanks for that Mat. I'll give them a buzz to get a price.. Hoopers or CBC are good for bearings and seals too. Even if the bearing has no numbers on them (sometimes the etching wears off) they can match them up for size.


pfillery - May 20th, 2014 at 08:45 PM

Does anyone sell reco generators? I have limited time to do the job and would prefer a weekend friendly solution. By the time I have it out and ready to look at, a lot of places would be closed.

Or any ideas on costs to have one reconditioned?

I know there's plenty of Chinese junk gennys out there too.