Board Logo

VW fuel injection vs carby's
kombi_kid - February 10th, 2004 at 08:26 PM

hey
whats the pro's and cons of original VW fual injection on 2L type 4 motors VS the carbies??
cheers
rhys


Flintstones - February 10th, 2004 at 09:48 PM

with injection is starts first time every time no matter what the condition is, no need to consistantly tune twin carbies.
Plus if you wanted more power later on, you can add a turbo, cause your half way there already with the injection. Just change the computer to a programmable, add bigger injectors, intercooler, and larger fuel pump. (your engine will need to be in good nick to go turbo though)

That'll shock a few people especially when your pulling away from then :D
Cheers


kombi_kid - February 10th, 2004 at 09:53 PM

i plan to go watercooled down the track this is just to get the kombi on the road and have both 2L EFI and 2L carby motor
cheers
rhys


mnsKmobi - February 11th, 2004 at 08:09 AM

If the FI and the motor it's on are in good condition I'd use it in preference to the carb motor.


kombi_kid - February 11th, 2004 at 05:10 PM

does EFI have any prone problems and is the EFI parts expensive??? dont know the condition of the EFI unit or the motor although the motor has good compression
cheers
rhys


KruizinKombi - February 13th, 2004 at 07:48 AM

I have heard that stock efi motors run lean at revs, but then other people I've spoken to believe that this isn't true. I'm undecided, so you'll have to make your own decision on this.

My efi 2L ran hard with very little maintenance. My biggest problem was sticky injectors, because I kept forgetting to put the Mobil Fuel Injector Cleaner in every third tank like my mechanic told me to. I believe PULP would render the stuff obsolete now though. :thumb

The only other problem I encountered was a blown diode in the control unit, which caused it to run on three cylinders. Trouble is, when my mechanic cleaned one, it moved to the next injector. :( Took him about 2 hours of removing, cleaning and testing injectors to work out what the problem was!! :jesus


kombi_kid - February 13th, 2004 at 09:39 PM

yer
dad reacons not to use the EFI motor cause u can get these sorts of problems!!! but i like the idea of turnin the key starting straight away and not tuning carbs!
cheers
rhys


DoNkEy - February 15th, 2004 at 02:54 PM

are FI 2l engine rare? I am after a kombi, FI be nice to have but are they common?


kombi_kid - February 15th, 2004 at 08:13 PM

abit more common then type 3 EFI's!!!
cheers
rhys


seagull - February 15th, 2004 at 08:28 PM

holden camera set up works very well Up hills ect no problems


KruizinKombi - February 16th, 2004 at 10:18 AM

Rhys, the problem I had was a once off, and considering how little maintenance my 1st kombi got in the 8 years of hard use I gave it, it did extremely well. Not to mention the fact that it was a 76 model that had probably not seen much maintenance prior to me owning it. I would definitely recommend FI over carbies. :thumb

Donkey, FI engines aren't exactly rare; I believe that most 2L '76 models were FI, as were a lot of 1800 '75 models. The problem is that in the 70's, FI was generally misunderstood, so a lot of owners opted to remove the FI setup and revert to carbies. As a result, the FI setup is somewhat uncommon these days, but not exactly sought after either, so relatively cheap.

As seagull indicated, other FI setups can be adapted to the kombi motor quite successfully. The kombi setup only has a 9 stage (from memory) vane-type airflow sensor and is very simplistic (and inefficient) when compared to the systems from later model cars. The danger when using EFI from another vehicle is that other vehicles are not mapped to provide the fuel requirements for a kombi, which is particularly important as the kombi is air-cooled and has more potential to overheat than a watercooled engine. This may not be an issue, but should be checked to make sure and the system chipped or remapped to suit the kombi's requirements.

I personally believe that the better option for those not wishing to use the stock FI setup would be to utilise a programmable aftermarket EFI setup, perhaps with the stock FI manifolds. While this is more costly, a decent aftermarket system will have more load points, and more sensor inputs so it can more efficiently determine the fuel requirements of the engine. A really good system will utilise an EGO (Exhaust Gas Oxygen) sensor to constantly retune itself as you drive. Higher end units will also control ignition timing, and can retard the ignition when the engine gets hot to prevent engine-killing pre-detonation. :thumb


kombi_kid - February 16th, 2004 at 09:44 PM

thanks for that colin helps alot!!
cheers
rhys


Robo - February 17th, 2004 at 06:45 AM

Hi Rhy's
I hope you dont mind me adding to your question (post) Im not trying to hijack it, I just want to know a bit more about it.
I would like to know more about this myself. Everyone seems to drool over twin Dellorto's, but from most mechanics I have spoken too (Not VW mechanics) Fuel injection is a much better option. with the price of dual Dell or Webber carb set ups ($1500-$2500) Fuel injection may be a more cost efective option. What sort of set up costs would be involved in doing this.