Board Logo

should a new engine leak oil?
HEL-70Y - November 10th, 2005 at 02:53 PM

Hi

I have recently had professionally built a 1916 and done about 2000km so far, and when i turn of my car i leak a couple drops from my rear main. Just wanted to know if this was normal for a new engine

Thanks

Sezer


MickH - November 10th, 2005 at 02:54 PM

No.Check the oil isn't overfilled,then take it back to who ever built it.:cussing


pete wood - November 10th, 2005 at 03:00 PM

could be a dodgy rear main. that's a pain as the motor has to come out but it's not serious.


VWCOOL - November 10th, 2005 at 03:00 PM

I woudl expect not - my older high-milers don't leak oil

Make sure it isn't gearbox oil...?


HEL-70Y - November 10th, 2005 at 03:20 PM

naa it's from the rear main, im quite sure. i told the mechanic about it a while ago and he just said all vw's leak oil...hmm perhaps i will have to ask him again next time i see him. thanks for the answers, i was hoping thats what you's would say coz i dont like paying all that money and coming back home with oil leaks on my driveway


Bizarre - November 10th, 2005 at 04:31 PM

You can damage the rear seals pretty easy if you have a bur on the flywheel
As well - people dont cange the O ring, and that can cause leaks.

Cam plug not glued in properly can stuff things and cause a leak

For good news - at least it is not leaking at the pulley end.
That would be crankcase pressure?? more than likely.

Pulling the motor, cleaning the flywheel, and replacing both the O ring AND the seal would be your best option.

See what you can negotiate with him on it


tassupervee - November 10th, 2005 at 07:02 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by HEL-70Y
i told the mechanic about it a while ago and he just said all vw's leak oil...

Oh please,what a complete dickhead of a mechanic.
Make the dickbrain fix it and never go back to him unless it leaks again.
What an arsehole. Not even a mechanics arsehole...........arrrrgh!
l8tr
E


jakjones - November 11th, 2005 at 06:06 PM

may be a crack in the case behind the fly-wheel, way beyond the control of the mechanic, did u ask for a 1916 ?
Did u specify a new crankcase ???

Tass I think u should calm down a little, I've no idea who's work your slagging but it's :alien bound to hurt some one.

[ Edited on 11-11-05 by jakjones ]


HotRodMatt - November 11th, 2005 at 07:10 PM

Maybe not even the mechanic... have you been flogging it? The last engine got a bit of a hiding!


Louis - November 11th, 2005 at 07:29 PM

#! Message No Longer Available !#


Robo - November 11th, 2005 at 09:21 PM

A freshly rebuilt engine that has been done by someone who knows what they are doing would be oil tight. Im afraid too many slack arse mechanics just use the old "they are supposed to leak a little bit" excuse too many times. Its not right, take it back and get them to sort it. If they won't, their scum and don't deserve your continued custom.
Rob...


bazzamon - November 13th, 2005 at 04:08 AM

Normally one would not expect an oil from a recently o/hauled motor. But as soon as you get away from the normal set up size crankcase pressure changes & can cause pressure at the most vunerable point. In this case I would suggest that you put up with a drop or 2 until the motor is fully run in. Piston/ring blow by occurs with most new engines & until the motor has run some 5 to 7K & the oil changed a couple of times leave it. I have expirenced the r/main leaking a few times with standard rebuilts & each time it cures itself. I would say to leave it until you have done at least 2 long trips & the warranty period is nearly up.It is not always the builders fault!


HEL-70Y - November 14th, 2005 at 12:37 PM

Thanks for all the advice guys.

i went to him because he knows what his doing,jak i did ask for a 1916 and it is still the same case which is not cracked, everything was done properly by a professional vw mech. matt, The last engine coped a little hiding at the nats, wasnt too bad, it was the gearbox mount which i screwed up then (which is why my engine was jumping everywhere and why it jumped out of first when i took off while i was racing the final:cry) which is all good now i had a new solid mount put in, and i havn't been flogging it (havnt even taken it to the runs to see what ill do yet), i take it easy most of the time and i did all the necessary wearing in just like the mech asked. louis its not pouring out only a drop or two. rob i'd have to say i totally agree with you

Im due for an oil change, so i will wait a little as buzzamon suggested, probably wait until it'is due for next full service and ill take it back to him to adjust the tappets and see what he says again about the leak. I have done a couple long trips, well depends what you class as long, i took it to the south coast and enterance and a few other 2 or so hour trips. I'll let you all know when the time comes with what happens.

Thanks again all for the words of wisdom


Purple Martin - November 15th, 2005 at 10:22 AM

Quote:
Originally posted by Louis
Show me a vw that doesnt leak oil.

The one in my avatar doesn't leak oil.