Hey guys. Trying to figure out what direction to take with my Fastback. Either a mild air cooled 1916 or a Subaru ej22. Has anyone had experiences with both of these engines in either a beetle or type 3. What are the pro's and con's with both the engines and what would feel faster?

thanks

go the Subi

What do you think my answer would be? Stay with the Suby but I honestly would enjoy the cruise with the EA81 until you have the rest of the car just ratted how you want it. Should you want more power, your 3/4 way to a conversion so just go the EJ22, hell lot cheaper than a 1916.

what they said. 1916 = $$$$$, EJ22 = $$$ but a much lazier therefore longer lasting engine.
a good 1916 is probably about the same power as the EJ22 and it's a fair bit lighter. however the price tag is not worth the motor for a street car in my opinion.

Yeah, I think if I could find a cheap Liberty for around $750 off ebay, I should be able to do the conversion for around $2000 minus the engineer cert. After researching about the EA series engines and driving the one in the fasty now, im not that impressed with the power increase compared to the air cooled. Also not much after market performance parts for these engines compared to VW engines.

the only real cons i see of the EJ is mainly the hacking involved to fit a radiator (which your car has had already??) and the initial cost of the install

oh yeah and all the uptight whingy purists

pros are easy

stock EJ22 will make same if not more power than most hot 1916s but be 100x smoother, economical and outlive by a long shot
theyre one of the most bullet proof subi motors out there

plus once its in if it dies another is only $500 away from most wreckers and if ones not availble an EJ20 can be used as well, not $6K+ down the drain

just a thought, if I were to do it again, I'd go the EJ20T. There are literally billions available and the number of parts available for them is beyond compare for any car except Chev V8s. You can start with a stock single sideplate box and upgrade later to albins gears. GTmac can word you up on it all.

Yeah the ej20T would be awesome, but alot more work and $$$$$. I think 135hp from the ej22 would be a nice step up from the 75hp that I have now. And I wont be smashing cv's and gears. Plus the ej20T usually cost over $2000 compared to $600 for a ej22.

The other option is an EA82T. I think it is only 120HP stock, but being turbo can easily be modified. The fuel economy will be worse (than the EJ22), but the giggle factor with the turbo is higher. Pete from Custom Offroad had one in his Baja, I drove it a few times and it went pretty well. The EA82T is cheap.

Hi

After spending another $1500+ to finish off a mild 1904cc Type 1 motor for the sons 1303, I'm wondering if I should have just gone EJ22 now instead of later.

Steve

you don't need to wonder, you know what the answer is

wats the limitations to engine vs. weight anyways?

can he go ej25,
is ej22 not compliant with any rules cause its too much?

I really don't know, but am keen. Could you imagine the upgrade! (it would be a long time yet mind you....)

what about the current ej20 series? subaru website says 110kw & 196nm, but i recall seeing it a year or so ago rated at 120kw (i'm probably imagining things). maybe it was detuned for emissions reasons?

I would only change to a ej20t heaps of fun and you can just drive it all day like a ej22 until you need the boost.

check out my link below

Hi,
This might convince u just to wait & do the EJ20T, as Ian says, the wrx engines drive like stockers until u get into them.
Personally I would have a hot VW engine over the EJ22 or even the EJ25. if u have the radiator setup, then u are 90% there, so just get the EJ20T, u won't be dissapointed.

Heres the graph of the last VW engine that I built, compared to the wrx engine.
VW engine was a 2275cc with all the goodies, but unfortunantly stock 040 heads & low 8.6:1 compression. Lots of tourque for a heavy superbug, but would have greatly benefitted from some nice CNC heads & 10.0:1 compression.
WRX engine was $850 with 140'000ks on it from SSS Automotive in Sydney. Engine was bought late 2004 but I have seen the WRX engines for as little as $750 at Echibahn jap wreckers in Sydney, try to steer away from the Liberty EJ20T's as they don't have the later model heads as per the WRX.
Hope this helps u.
regards
Jak

Quote:

Originally posted by ian.mezz I would only change to a ej20t heaps of fun and you can just drive it all day like a ej22 until you need the boost. check out my link below

I swing both ways.

In our Type 4 engined bus the EJ22 fitted straight in, and the radiator bolted straight underneath. No cutting of anything from the body or modifying anything mechanically at all. Just cost heaps of money.

In a Type 1 engined car I would go the real tough Type 1. That would bolt straight in.

However. If I did decide to put a Suby in the Type 1 engined vehicle, I would go the EJ20T. Might as well go extreme if you have to do all the work.

The way I see it, the engine brand designates the brand that wins the race. If you beat a Commodore in a Subaru engined Volkswagen, the Subaru brand was the winner. If you have a real tough VW engine and can beat Commodores at the drags, then VW wins.

Yeah im definitely swinging towards the ej20T.

I had no dramas engineering the ej20t in the wagon , rs legacy /liberty motors are alot cheaper then wrx i paid 2500 for 55k front cut and 1500 for a 140k cut, but yeah downside is noisy lifters , diff heads manifold and pistons fix that or wait till you find a sti front cut .

Hi Satori, i have an EJ20T with 95k on it if you are interested. It is still sitting in my 2001 Forester, i was going to put it in my T3 but i now have two 70's Kombi's that i'm now working on so the project is off and the Caravelle is to be sold. I'm on the Central Coast.
PM me if you wish or post here
Cheers Steve

So is there any problems using later model wrx engines around 2002 to 2005. I heard that immobilises can be a bit tricky to get around

if you use the jdm ones there isnt a problem.

Satori, i will PM you later on tonight.