Board Logo

jap import engine or aircooled?
Learner - March 8th, 2007 at 11:33 AM

I am still undecided if i wanty jap import or aircooled.
I understand that aircooled would be more exp than jap. (powerwise)

what would be the cost to transplant the engine? (for the jap) i know i can get front cuts for less than 5000

and again if i go jap what the main engines i should consider for it? sub or rotary? any other engines?

Am i wrong when i say that it's possible the lift the gearbox and engine for more clearance?

i guess with japs u get the comfort of heating and ac?


13bwagon - March 9th, 2007 at 08:41 PM

jap job= 8k with all the shite you need
don't go rotary unless you have a realy high ratio gear box
stay air cool for a cheap job go subi if you have the bucks


64vwmark - March 9th, 2007 at 09:16 PM

I would keep it simple and stick with the air cooled motor.

If you are quite experienced with engine conversions then go for it, but if you aren't, expect to pay bulk $$$ if you going to get someone else to do it.


subibaja - March 17th, 2007 at 10:24 AM

Quote:
Originally posted by 64vwmark
I would keep it simple and stick with the air cooled motor.

If you are quite experienced with engine conversions then go for it, but if you aren't, expect to pay bulk $$$ if you going to get someone else to do it.


whats big bucks
8000or so for a big vw motor once you get all the bits carbs and that and it will not be as reliable
or
do it yourself jap stuff
i did mine for about 4000
with 140 hp and reliability
yes i used to work at custom and had the tools there
but surely if you ask enough questions from the right people
you,ll be right

your call but i know you wont see me going back


Learner - March 17th, 2007 at 09:39 PM

yes i am really tempted to go jap but i have no mechanic knowledge. would i be able to learn just by asking quetions? i am a fast learner...

as for what engine:
i was thinking of nissan?VQ25DD
toyota: 4GR-FSE or 2MZ-FE
or even mazda kl-ze
(nissan ones would be well exp.)


bond - March 18th, 2007 at 09:56 AM

thats a good idea - put any one of those engines in - you'll be fine - should bolt straight up. nothing to learn. easy as pie and cheap as chips!

goodluck

nick


helbus - March 18th, 2007 at 10:20 AM

This may sound like I am commenting from the dark side. I see merits in a lot of engine types. I am not specifically a brand person. I really enjoy the coolness and simplicity of dak daking in our aircooled Beetle. I have no races to win.

In the bus, the Suby 2.2 is perfect for highway cruising and effortless hill climbing ability and really good economy and reliability, again not a race winner.

If I wanted to have some Baja fun, I personally would like to have fun in a hi-powered type 1 based engine. I would love to see the looks on people faces when the little bug can give them a right old scare on the street, and have a ball in the scrub.

If I wanted more serious track Beetle action I would try for a turbo rotary or turbo 2.0 Suby application. It would take some serious money to make a serious car, but again it would be fun. Yeah?

At the end of the day I would certainly not do specifically what other people tell me to do, as most people have different opinions. I wouldn't even start on asking what bore or stroke type 1 engine setup people recommend. Go with what your budget can afford at this stage and go from there. You won't enjoy a half finished project that you can't drive.


Learner - March 18th, 2007 at 11:39 AM

i don't think all those engines are just bolt in i know wex as a klze an had to cut as for the ohers i have never seen or heard it done.


Baja Wes - March 19th, 2007 at 09:04 AM

Well I love my V6, and won't go back to a VW engine unless it is in something that I rarely have to drive.

Read through my website and the V6 transplant diary. If you think you can do the stuff in there, then go for it.

The EJ22 like Terry has is a great choice, because you don't need to cut or go crazy with support frames. Also Brad at COR has done heaps and can help out with advice and teething problems.


pete wood - March 21st, 2007 at 11:49 AM

gotta ask yourself a few questions.

1. are you are VW purist? if so stick with a VW motor
2. are you low on money? $2k gets you a nice 1640 that will go great offroad.
3. do you want real power? VW motors don't make real power for under $10k. A subaru Ej20 turbo puts out 200hp plus for a lot less.
4. do you want to be able to buy parts anywhere? VW parts for hipo engines are not available at repco. stock subaru parts are.