Board Logo

Much ado about matching numbers
ClockworkMonkey - February 17th, 2010 at 05:02 PM

Hey guys .. just thought i would ask u all about u think i should do to my motor?

I'm in the process of saving my pennies to start my little project. I was looking at engines online and it got me thinking... am i better saving my original motor (matching numbered 1500 single port) and keeping it somewhere or should i use it as a base and build on it?

Its my daily driver and i don't think i'm ever gonna sell it (i love it too much :) ) do u think its worth holding onto?


Joel - February 17th, 2010 at 07:35 PM

are you keeping the car fully stock?

mine still had the factory engine as listed in the dealership logbook and original purchase reciept when i bought it
its still sitting under my house now as like you i'm big on the matching numbers thing aswell as i kept the car all stock to start with but its slowly ended up more and more modified so that engine will probably sit for eternity now

just something to think about
if your planning a concouse restoration one day then keep it aside otherwise if its a good sound block then why not use it?


Camo - February 17th, 2010 at 08:24 PM

Also, if it's your daily driver think of the extra time the car will be off the road after you pull your motor out, strip it down, send it off for checking and if ok then having it all machined and then rebuilding etc.

If you build up another engine whilst still driving your car, you will probably only have the car off the road for half a day.

And as Joel said, keep original under the house. If you every have trouble with the hot motor, you can always pull it out, whack the original back in whilst working on the hottie and still keep the car on the road. And if you love the motor and want to keep it but sell the car to upgrade - well you know this answer.

Something to think about, Kev


matberry - February 17th, 2010 at 08:32 PM

I agree with keeping the og for all the above reasons, + a performance metor really needs a sound base, a new block, not one that has gone rotten from too many hot-cold cycles, even in a good stock rebuild often the case isn't up to scratch, so while it's still running, keep it that way.


68AutoBug - February 18th, 2010 at 11:17 AM

Quote:
Originally posted by ClockworkMonkey
Hey guys .. just thought i would ask u all about u think i should do to my motor?

I'm in the process of saving my pennies to start my little project. I was looking at engines online and it got me thinking... am i better saving my original motor (matching numbered 1500 single port) and keeping it somewhere or should i use it as a base and build on it?

Its my daily driver and i don't think i'm ever gonna sell it (i love it too much :) ) do u think its worth holding onto?


KEEP it standard.....
for a spare....

the 1500 single port engines are good....

I used mine... in My beetle... but have a spare...

not many beetles have the original engine in them...

it doesn't worry Me really... matching numbers..

LEE


Phil74Camper - February 18th, 2010 at 12:23 PM

In fact matching numbers are not even necessary for VW councours shows - at least at the VW Nationals. If you enter in the 'Standard' category, the judges would expect to see a 'standard' looking engine but wouldn't care if its an H or AD or anything else. You aren't maked down for non-original engine, so long as it is still in original-style layout. The cars are judged on cleanliness and attention to detail in its presentation.

All that matching numbers and 1960s air in the tyres stuff is for the Jaguar and MG crowd - we don't do it.


ClockworkMonkey - March 1st, 2010 at 12:12 PM

yeah i'm not too concerned about it either ... i think it might be a good idea to keep it just as a spare just in cases though. its a good little motor, but i am saving up for a bit more bang :)


jsheppard64 - March 4th, 2010 at 12:51 AM

Quote:
Originally posted by 68AutoBug

it doesn't worry Me really... matching numbers..

LEE


It looks like color coding your motor worries you.


Joel - March 4th, 2010 at 10:48 AM

we got some sharp ones around here :lol: